Given the failure of many government legislations in achieving the objectives for which they were formulated, a case for institutionalising deeper public consultations in the legislative process has been made in the recent past. Currently, there are four entry points where citizens can participate in the legislative process: first, the identifying stage; second, the drafting stage; third, the legislative stage; and fourth, the post-legislative stage.
Civil society organisations can alert the government to the need for a particular legislation or changes in an existing law. The Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, a farmers and workers group, ran a successful campaign for a Right to Information law, which was finally enacted in 2005. The recent anti-corruption agitation led to the introduction of a Lokpal Bill currently pending in the Rajya Sabha. The long-running Right to Food campaign by a network of NGOs has been instrumental in raising awareness about chronic hunger and the eventual introduction of the National Food Security Bill in 2011.
The government can also suo moto decide that a law is required in a particular sector. It may get inputs from specialised bodies such as the National Human Rights Commission and the Law Commission or appoint a group to study a sector and draft a law. These groups or bodies may hold consultations with independent experts and stakeholders. Furthermore, an individual Member of Parliament (MP) can also introduce a Bill in either House. This is known as a Private Member’s Bill (for example, Lok Sabha MP, Kalikesh Singh Deo introduced the Disclosure of Lobbying Activities Bill in 2013 to regulate lobbying activities). Although these are generally never passed, they act as signalling devices to the government, which may introduce its own legislation on the subject. It is possible for the public to approach their constituency representatives to advocate for a particular law.
Government Bills are drafted by the concerned ministry, which is then vetted by other ministries. There are also times when the government approaches an independent expert to draft a law. Recently, it appointed the Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission, under the chairmanship of Justice BN Srikrishna to reform the financial sector laws.
The government may publish the draft legislation in the public domain for feedback. Drafts of the Electronic Service Delivery Bill, the National Sports Bill and the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Bill were published for a specified time period (generally 20-30 days). It may also circulate the draft among a select set of stakeholders for comments. An individual MP may solicit public feedback on his Private Member Legislation. For example, Biju Janata Dal, MP Baijayant Panda uses his personal website and social media tools such as Facebook to publicise the draft of his private member bills.
There are few avenues of public engagement once the Bill is introduced in the Parliament. Since 1993, 24 Department-related Standing Committees (DRSCs) were formed to scrutinise Bills and other policies of the Government (before 1993 Bills were sometimes referred to ad-hoc committees for scrutiny). Generally most Bills are referred to these DRSCs, however, the presiding officer of the House has the discretion not to do so. For instance, key Bills such as the Special Economic Zones Bill, 2005 and the National Investigation Agency Bill, 2008 were not referred to a DRSC. In contrast, the Lokpal Bill passed by the Lok Sabha was sent to a Select Committee by the Rajya Sabha although it had been examined by the DRSC.
These DRSCs may solicit feedback from the public by issuing notices in key newspapers and the Gazette of India. The public comments are also tabled in the form of a report. However, the level of public engagement varies with different Bills. For instance, the DRSC scrutinising the Companies Bill, 2009 received 101 comments while only 10 submissions were received for the Armed Forces Tribunal (Amendment) Bill, 2012.
The government is not bound to accept the recommendations of the DRSC but individual MPs may introduce amendments to the Bill when it is being considered by the House. The MP may suggest amendments based on the DRSC’s suggestions or any public feedback.
Once Bills are enacted, ministries draft and notify Rules (also known as subordinate legislation) to enable their implementation. These Rules may be scrutinised by the Subordinate Legislation Committee, which is empowered to seek public feedback.
Post legislative scrutiny of laws is not mandatory in India. It may however be undertaken by bodies such as the Law Commission of India, the DRSCs or a specific commission appointed for the purpose who may hold public consultations. Recently, rape laws were reviewed by the Justice Verma Committee before an Ordinance was promulgated on the matter.
Many other democracies have devised meaningful ways to encourage public participation in the legislative process. In countries such as the UK, Australia and South Africa, it is mandatory to hold public consultations or publish draft Bills for comments. In fact, in South Africa it is a constitutionally mandated provision. In the UK, the Government publishes Green Paper and White Paper, which sets out its central ideas on the Bill. After introduction, it is compulsory to refer a Bill to a committee in the UK and the US. However, there is no such requirement in Australia, Canada and South Africa. Unlike in India and South Africa, it is mandatory for the Government in countries such as the UK, Australia and Canada to respond to the recommendations of the committee. While post legislative scrutiny in India is largely a matter of discretion of the Government, in the UK it is compulsory to do so within three to five years. In the US, legislative oversight committees review laws on a continuous basis. In Australia, most laws have to be reviewed within three years. Public comments are also solicited during the post-legislative scrutiny.
India can learn from the experience of these countries and tailor them to suit our requirements. There are many ways in which the government can deepen public engagement in the legislative process.
First, ministries can be mandatorily required to publish the draft Bill for a reasonable time and publicise it through different media. Along with the draft Bill, the ministry may be required to include available background information on the subject and facilitate access to legal and legislative record on the matter.
Second, it should be compulsory to refer a Bill to a DRSC or select committee for scrutiny. This could be at both the pre-legislative stage and the legislative stage. These committees should be required to hold wide consultations with a variety of stakeholders (NGOs, state and local governments, special interest groups, academics and legal experts). Public participation may be facilitated by increasing access to constituency offices, using a variety of media outlets to publicise the Bill and creating public participation offices that can interface with the public.
Third, in order to increase transparency in the feedback process, the government could be required to publish a report demonstrating how the inputs from stakeholders have been considered while formulating the law.
Fourth, most Acts should be subject to a post legislative scrutiny through public engagement every three to five years. This could be carried out if each Bill includes an Explanatory Note giving the criteria or outcomes by which the Bill could be judged for effectiveness. This responsibility could be given to a specialised committee.
Such measures will result in robust legislations, which shall need lesser amendments and will be successful in achieving the objective with which that legislation was enacted.
This article was first published in Pragati on May 3, 2013.
Hi, I &X64;o beliеve this is an excelle&X6e;t sіte.
I stumbled&X75;pon іt 😉 I ωill come back yet agai&X6e;
since i have boο&X6b;marked it.
Money and freeԁom is the gгеatest ωay to change, may &X79;o&X75; &X62;e гich anԁ co&X6e;tinuе
to guidе οthers.
Not too long ago, I didnt give heaps of considered to help leaving observations on internet webpage page articles or blog posts and provide put suggestions even far significantly less. Looking through in your excellent write-up, will let me to do occasionally
Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to send you an email.
I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be
interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to
seeing it expand over time.
Here is my blog: first impressions molds
Hi there, I identified your net internet site through Google at the identical time as hunting for a equivalent topic, your web site arrived up, it looks great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
I was suggested this weblog by my cousin. I am not confident whether or not this publish is created by him as no one else know this sort of detailed about my trouble. You are incredible! Many thanks!
It was really helpful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the foreseeable future as nicely. This was in fact what I was seeking for, and I am happy to came listed here! Thanks for sharing this kind of a information with us.
Besides Raja and Kanimozhi, other accused in the case include Unitech Wireless managing director Sanjay Chandra, Swan Telecoms director Vinod Goenka, former telecom secretary Siddhartha Behura, DMK-run Kalaignar TVs MD Sharad Kumar, Bollywood filmmaker Karim Morani and Reliance Anil Dhirubhai Ambani groups executives Hari Nair, Gautam Doshi and Surendra Pipara.Senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Yashwant Sinha on Tuesday informed that he has written a letter to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh stating he is ‘surprised and disappointed’ over his refusal to depose before the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) on 2G scam.
[url=http://www.lululemonoutlet-canada.tk/]Lululemon Canada[/url]
Lululemon Canada
Awesome, exactly what I’ve been looking for.
Thanks a great post, cheers. http://bizoppreviews233.com
Terrific article! That is the kind of information that are meant to be shared around the net. Shame on the seek engines for no longer positioning this put up upper! Come on over and talk over with my web site . Thanks =)
I really like it whenever people come together and share views. Great website, continue the good work!|
Michael Kors Outlet
Keep on working, great job!|
Moncler jacka Sverige
Wow, this piece of writing is pleasant, my sister is analyzing these kinds of things, therefore I am going to convey her.|
Cheap North Face Jackets
Ahaa, its nice conversation about this piece of writing at this place at this blog,
I have read all that, so now me also commenting at this place.
I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. appreciate it
Outstanding posting. I’d been looking at constantly this kind of website exactly what astounded! Very beneficial information specially the outstanding portion 🙂 My partner and i deal with similarly info much. I was in search of this particular specified information for a very long time. Thank you and also regarding good luck.
Fantastic post.Much thanks again.
I simply want to say I am just newbie to blogging and seriously liked your web blog. Most likely I’m going to bookmark your blog post . You absolutely have really good writings. Thanks for sharing with us your blog.
I am not sure where you’re getting your information, but good topic.
I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more.
Thanks for great info I was looking for this info for my mission.
I just want to say I am just all new to blogs and truly enjoyed you’re page. Almost certainly I’m likely to bookmark your site . You absolutely come with excellent writings. Many thanks for sharing with us your web page.
I think such a programme is necessary to head off dangerous climate change. But even if I am wrong, it would make the world a better, more prosperous place. Could all sides back it while continuing to argue about the science? That really would be a shock.
Chaussure Air Jordan Homme http://airjordanhomme-fr.smalltownmentality.com/
Chaussure Air Jordan Homme
Many thanks! Loads of facts!
Thanks very nice blog!
I just want to say I am newbie to weblog and truly savored your web page. Most likely I’m going to bookmark your website . You really have amazing article content. Thanks for revealing your webpage.
Hi, yes this piece of writing is in fact good and I have learned lot of things
from it on the topic of blogging. thanks.
Thanks on your marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading
it, you will be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your
blog and will eventually come back very soon. I want to encourage
continue your great posts, have a nice holiday weekend!
An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a colleague who was conducting a little research on this.
And he actually bought me lunch due to the fact that I discovered it
for him… lol. So let me reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!!
But yeah, thanks for spending time to discuss this issue
here on your web site.
What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this web page regularly, this web page is really pleasant and the users are truly sharing pleasant thoughts.
best for you.good !!!
thats what i wantred to know.thanks. good !!!
Keep it up, great job! Just the stuff I had to know.
I found some good info in your site and bookmarked to visit again . Thanks.
Some really interesting information , well written and broadly speaking user pleasant.
Hello, Neat post. There is really a problem with your internet site in internet explorer, could test this¡K IE nonetheless may be the marketplace leader and a large portion of folks will leave out your exceptional writing due to this dilemma.
It is extremely interesting topic you’ve written here . The truth I’m not related to this, but I feel is really a very good opportunity to learn more about, And as properly talk about a different subject to which I used to speak with others
There is little free thinking at all.
I was trying to discover this. Actually refreshing take on the information. Thanks a whole lot.
I can see that you are putting a lots of efforts into your blog. Keep posting the good work.Some really helpful information in there. Bookmarked. Nice to see your site. Thanks!
I just want to mention I’m all new to weblog and truly enjoyed this blog site. Likely I’m want to bookmark your blog post . You surely come with wonderful articles and reviews. Regards for revealing your web site.
You produced some decent points there. I looked online for the problem and found most people will go along with together with your web page.