By Rajesh Chakrabarti, Executive Director, Bharti Institute of Public Policy, ISB
This article was first published in the Economic Times on Oct 31, 2013
The current controversy over the coal block allotment is perhaps the latest and one of the most sordid examples of inefficient allocation of national resources, but the malaise is hardly new.
In fact, in an interview back in 2010, Raghuram Rajan had identified favoured allocation of resources as the driving force behind the fortunes of many billionaires in India – a nation that ranked second only to Russia in terms of the number of billionaires per trillion dollar of GDP.
How then to best allocate national resources – mining rights and telecommunication spectrum – in an efficient manner? Auctions come to mind immediately as competitive and transparent mechanisms of allocating resources. They allocate resources to the highest valuer, ensuring both socially most productive allocation as well as maximum revenue gathering by the exchequer.
Still a Surprise Element
But governments around the world have long used auctions to allocate resources and yet the mechanism has at times thrown nasty surprises. Auctions can be of several types and the success of the mechanism depends critically on its design.
Take, for instance, the 3G spectrum auction in six European countries in 2000. While in UK and Germany, the auction yielded prices over 600 per person, in Switzerland, the yield came to only 20, about 5% of the predicted value. In 1999, in Germany, as spectrum was being auctioned in 10 blocks, Mannesman and T-Mobile colluded to split the spectrum between themselves, each picking up half the offering at a very low price.
A successful allocation mechanism should ensure widespread participation, a prerequisite for competition. It should also prevent collusion so that each bidder reveals close to its true reserve price for the item or items being auctioned.
Sealed with a Dutch
Broadly, auctions follow two formats: ascending, or “Anglo”, approach where an auctioneer keeps raising prices till there is only one bidder left (there is a descending version as well); and sealed-bid, or “Dutch”, auction where bids are simultaneously revealed. The former has the advantage of transparency, price discovery and revenue maximisation, but, in the presence of one or more “strong” players, may end up discouraging participation by smaller players, in the absence of which the supposed “stronger” player can get away with offering significantly less than what it truly values the resource at.
A mix of the two, “Anglo-Dutch”, is sometimes resorted to that runs the “Anglo” way till only two bidders are left in the fray, and then switches to “Dutch” with the floor of the last price of the Anglo auction.
Another deterrence for auctions is the infamous “winner’s curse”, referring to the fact that the actual winner is likely to be the party that has overvalued the resource the most. The issue is particularly significant when the resource being auctioned, like mining rights, whether land or offshore, is difficult to value. This is where valuation becomes critical.
“Common-value” resources like oil, that are valued pretty much the same way per unit by all parties, but whose supply per block is something each bidder is uncertain about, differ from “private-value” items to which bidders assign different values irrespective of the valuation given by others. The “winner’s curse” problem is strongest in the former.
Tailor-Made for Scam
A standard solution to this problem is the “second-price” option where the highest bidder gets the resource but pays the next highest bidder’s bid. A common result: less hesitation to bid on the higher side. But even this can throw uncomfortable surprises. Consider the embarrassment of the New Zealand auctioneer – and the immediate suspicion of foul play had it been in a country like India – when a winner bidding NZ$7 million walked away paying the next highest price of NZ$5,000! Clearly, the presence of a reserve price is essential to avoid such situations.
While under certain, rather unrealistic assumptions, all major auction designs would yield the same results, in reality, the suitability of the design to the resource being auctioned, the nature of information about it and the nature of competition among bidders hold the key to the success of the auction process.
Then, one has to pay attention to other auctions as well. Turkey auctioned two mobile telephone licences in 2000; sequentially, with the condition that the price of the second auction could not fall short of the first. The result? The winner of the first auction bid (and paid) a price so high that it could never be worth with two rivals in competition. The second licence, naturally, went unclaimed!
Rules and punishments are not beyond question either. The design issues apply not just to minerals – coal or offshore oil, for instance – but also to PPP projects where we have often seen re-negotiations and cost escalations. Auctions are better than the first-come-first-served or government-determined allocation, but their outcomes depend critically on the appropriateness of their design.
DISCLAIMER : Any comments, speeches, articles, blogs, podcasts, videos/vlogs, opposite the editorial page/opinions andeditorials page (OP-ED), interview response etc. made by individuals should be accompanied by a clear disclaimer from the ones given below.
“The views expressed in this article are personal. Prof Rajesh Chakrabarti is a faculty at the Indian School of Business.”
You are so great! I dona??t think Ia??ve read anything at all like this before. So great to locate someone with some authentic feelings on this subject. Many thanks for commencing this up. tava tea
bottes mellow yellow jamalaya http://bottes-mellow-yellow.shastadatadirector.com
I consider now I have a robust maintain in excess of the subject matter after heading by means of the publish. I will definitely come back for much more info. I have bookmark this report..
Once my young children are sleeping me and my husband enjoy reading helpful articles or blog posts over the internet of which we could relate to our occupations or even personal activities. Outstanding post!
http://www.viajefindeestudios.com/Readme.html http://www.viajefindeestudios.com/Readme.html
Hurrah, that’s what I was seeking for, what a material! existing here at this blog, thanks admin of this web site.
michael kors mk5128 http://www.ruekert-mielke.com/michaelkors/index.asp?id=83
You’ve maԁe some гeally good points there.
I checked on thе internet tο finԁ out more about the іssue an&X64;
found most ρeople will go along ωith your vіews οn this
ωebsite.
Many thanks for having the time to go over this, I feel strongly about it and love studying a lot more on this subject. If achievable, as you gain knowledge, would you brain updating your blog with far more data? It is really helpful and advantageous to your viewers.
Quality articles or reviews is the crucial to be a
focus for the users to pay a visit the website,
that’s what this web site is providing.
I every time spent my half a&X6E; hour &X74;o геad this blog’s posts daіly a&X6C;ong &X77;it&X68; a cup of coffeе.
Heya і am &X66;or the prі&X6d;аrу tіme herе.
ӏ сame across thіs board and I finԁ It truhly useful & it helpеd me οut a lot.
I’&X6d; hoping to offeг ѕ&X6f;m&X65;thing back and help others such as &X79;ou a&X69;ded me.
whoah this blog is wonderful i really like studying your articles. Keep up the good work! You realize, many people are hunting around for this information, you can help them greatly.
Hi there, You have done an excellent job. I will certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.
learn hindi online http://learninghindionline.tumblr.com/
Hi, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Chrome, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, very good blog!
The Prime Minister has confirmed the carbon tax will be replaced by an emissions trading scheme, at a cost to the budget of $3.8 billion over the next four years, with this to be offset by cutting $356 million in funding from the Biodiversity Fund and Carbon Farming Futures, among other programs.National Farmers’ Federation CEO Matt Linnegar said it was disappointing the Government had chosen to fund its new emissions trading scheme, aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions, by cutting funding to two important programs that help farmers store carbon and continue their work as Australia’s frontline environmentalists.”Cutting the carbon tax is something the NFF had long advocated for, due to the additional and unnecessary costs it adds into Australian farm businesses. The early move to an emissions trading scheme will reduce these costs, because the current international carbon price is lower than the fixed price under the tax,” Mr Linnegar said.”But the decision by the Government to offset the cost of moving to an emissions trading scheme by scrapping unallocated funds from the Biodiversity Fund and the Carbon Farming Futures program means they risk, once again, robbing Peter to pay Paul.”The Carbon Farming Futures program delivers the science and extension to help farmers manage their land in way that reduces emissions and leads to enhanced productivity and sustainability. Today, the Government announced they are cutting the program funding by one third. Meanwhile the Biodiversity Fund helps farmers store carbon, enhance biodiversity and build greater environmental resilience and its funding will be cut by close to a quarter.”At this stage, it is unclear as to whether the earlier move to the emissions trading scheme will result in a better deal for the farm sector.”Toowoomba Newspapers Pty Ltd 2013.APN APN Group WebsitesNeed Help? Refer to our helpful FAQ section for any problems you might be experiencing.Toowoomba Chronicle Toowoomba News National News World News Sport Entertainment Movie News TV News Lifestyle Travel Shopping Business Real Estate Home Loans Horoscopes Toowoomba Weather Newspapers in EducationWhat’s on TV Guide Now/Next Movies Movie ReviewsToowoomba Classifieds Jobs in Toowoomba Cars for Sale in Toowoomba Property listings in Toowoomba Bargains for Sale in Toowoomba Obituaries in Toowoomba Personals in Toowoomba Notices in Toowoomba锘縁armers welcome proposed wind farm Nike Blazer The mine was vital to boosting Cape York’s economy and would have provided much needed employment in the area, he says. The LD4/5 location provides access to dozens of liquidity providers, matching engines and more than 35 carrier networks as well as the London Internet Exchange (LINX). This provides FCM360 clients with low latency cross connect capabilities to the world’s largest community of execution venues and other financial market participants. This enables them to exchange data more efficiently, decrease execution times and increase trading volumes. Nike Blazer Global map regions available to purchase and store on the device as Air Jordan Retro Shoes Facebook gained 64 cents, or 3.8 percent, to $18.41 after its CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced he will not sell any shares for a year. The company also announced a major share buyback. New Womens Nike Air Max 2013 Premium Purple Grey US On Sale Discount Nike Air Max US 3) You fail to take into account the other benefits of the program, such as reduced emissions reducing respitory ailments, and oh yeah, the other big idea was to the working poor out of older, less reliable cars and into newer, theoretically more reliable cars (your mileage may vary). Nike Air Max US Delta Air Lines rose 80 cents, or 3.2 %, to 25.49 dollars . The airline made more than a billion dollars in the third quarter as more passengers paid a little bit extra to fly. Delta also said it was seeing strong holiday bookings. Charles Victory Puts Coach On Verge Of A Milestone
The original objective of the Climate Treaty was to put in place legally binding emission reduction targets for the historic polluters, who in the pre globalisation period were concentrated in the rich industrial North. The treaty was destroyed at the Climate summit in Copenhagen, by an attempt to replace it with a non binding Copenhagen Accord. The Kyoto Protocol introduced emissions trading, which in effect meant the polluter got paid, not punished. The big industrial polluters were first paid by allowing them to get private rights to our atmospheric commons. They then got paid by profiting from carbon trading. Coach Darren Austin said it was a nervous start for the girls who let the first few goals go to the opposition. http://www.cheapbaseballjerseysmlb.com/toronto-blue-jays-jerseys-c-4/ Arizona Diamondbacks Jerseys Health care stocks have also led gains in the S 500 this year, rising 38 percent. The industry is attractive to investors. Some of its companies, like Biogen Idec, offer the possibility of explosive growth. Others are established players like Pfizer, which pays big dividends. Health insurance companies have also done well this year as the Affordable Care Act rolls out. Coast Prom Dresses As The Daily Telegraph first reported in July 2003, two pupils at Winchester let the cat out of the bag when they hacked into the school’s computer and found the Sevenoaks survey. sanctions. http://www.cheapbaseballjerseysmlb.com/los-angeles-dodgers-jerseys-c-10/ Washington Nationals Authentic Stephen Strasburg 2013 USMC Home Cool Base Jersey – (Mens Authentic) New York Mets Youth Replica Home Jersey with All Star 2013 Patch by Majestic Athletic – (Kids) 319D Old Coast Rd Australind Seller wants them sold! Make an offer New Greens LYLA MAXI DRESS – Coast Maxi Dresses Genio’s license agreement provides it with access to hundreds of Mighty Beanz characters for use in a collectible trading card game series aimed at children ages 5 12. The initial launch of the Mighty Beanz series of Genio Cards features 131 different cards. The first series of cards (Moon Quest series) consists of 2 SKUs a 9 card booster pack In collectible card games and collectible miniature wargames, a booster pack is a sealed package of cards or figurines, designed to add to a player’s collection.
rhqaYn Awesome article.Thanks Again. Want more.
Awesome issues here. I’m very glad to peer your article. Thanks so much and I’m having a look ahead to touch you.
Will you kindly drop me a mail?
Here is my web blog – laser spine institute
I just want to tell you that I’m beginner to blogs and seriously liked your blog. Likely I’m planning to bookmark your blog . You definitely come with very good stories. Kudos for sharing your website.
hey there! , Is fantastic crafting and so a whole lot! portion all of us connect a little more about this page upon Yahoo? I personally need to have a expert within this space or room in order to solve my own issue. Might be which is you actually! Looking towards look at you.
Hi, yes this article is really nice and I have learned lot of things from it on
the topic of blogging. thanks.
Thanks for finally writing about > Coal block allotment:
Getting the auctions right | Bharti Institute of Public Policy < Liked it!
Also visit my webpage; buscadores internet
I nеed to to thank you fօr this excellent read!!
I absolutely loved every little bit of it. I’ve got you book-marked to
checк out new things you post…
Hello there, I found your internet-site by using Bing whilst seeking a linked matter, your web site got here right up, it seems good. I’ve truly combined with favourites types|added to bookmarks.
Valuable information. Fortunate me I discovered your site accidentally, and I’m shocked why this coincidence didn’t happened in advance! I bookmarked it.
I every time used to read post in news papers but now as I am a user of web thus from now
I am using net for articles, thanks to web.
wonderful stuff. good !!! good for me atleast !!!!
This ϲan be a challenging suЬject to create on! Great job on challenging oոeself and I hօpe far morе web writers take just after yoսr ambition!
thats what i wantred to know.thanks. good !!!
Great article! That is the kind of info that should be shared
around the internet. Disgrace on Google for no longer positioning this
put up upper! Come on over and talk over with my web site .
Thanks =)
I saw lots of website but I think this one contains something particular in it in it
I really like your wordpress template, exactly where do you get a hold of it through?
I’m glad to be a visitor of this perfect internet blog ! , regards for this rare details! .
Wanted posting. Loads of exceptional writing here. I wish I saw it found the website sooner. Congrats!
Wonderful post, I conceive internet site owners should larn a lot from this site its quite user friendly .
I loved your blog. Great.
high pr backlinks
Wow! what an idea ! What a thought ! Superb .. Amazing
I’m having a weird issue I cannot make my reader pick up your rss feed, I’m using google reader by the way.
Hello there I am so happy I found your site,
I really found you by error, while I was researching
on Askjeeve for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just like to say many thanks for
a marvelous post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to browse it all at the moment but I have book-marked it and also added your RSS feeds, so
when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the excellent jo.
I just couldn’t go away your website before suggesting that I really enjoyed the standard details an individual provide on your visitors? Is gonna be back often so that you can inspect new posts.
bookmarked!!, I love your blog!
An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a
coworker who had been conducting a little homework on
this. And he actually ordered me lunch due to the fact that I discovered it for him…
lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the
meal!! But yeah, thanks for spending time to discuss this matter here on your website.
Wow, superb weblog format! How long have you ever been
blogging for? you made running a blog look easy.
The overall look of your web site is great, let alone the content!
I really like what you guys are up too. Such clever work and exposure!
Keep up the good works guys I’ve included you guys to my personal blogroll.
Hi there! I just wish to offer you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you
have here on this post. I will be coming back to your web site for more soon.
Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it
but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some ideas for your blog you might
be interested in hearing. Either way, great website
and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.
Feel free to visit my blog visual impact cardio
I like the helpful info you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly.
I am quite certain I’ll learn lots of new stuff right here!
Best of luck for the next!
I’m not sure why but this blog is loading incredibly slow
for me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a problem on my end?
I’ll check back later and see if the problem still exists.
Hi, I do think this is an excellent site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I’m going to come
back yet again since I saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom
is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.
I’m very happy to find this great site. I want to to
thank you for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely savored every part of it and
I have you saved to fav to see new things in your site.
I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you make this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply as I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. kudos