Guest post by Krishnamurthy Subramanian, Assistant Professor, Finance, ISB and Prasanna Tantri, Associate Director, Centre for Analytical Finance, ISB
This article was first published in the Times of India on Oct 30, 2013
Does good economics make for good politics? Historically, in India, good economics hasn’t been considered good politics. However, recent experiences in Gujarat, Bihar, Odisha, Chhattisgarh, Haryana and Madhya Pradesh have pushed forward the view that good economics can make for good politics as well. Nevertheless, anecdotes can’t substitute for systematic evidence.
Poonam Gupta and Arvind Panagariya study the 2009 Lok Sabha elections and find that candidates of incumbent parties in states that recorded high growth won more often than their counterparts in states that recorded low growth. The 2009 elections followed a period of high growth in the economy. Therefore, evidence from the 2009 elections may be an exception rather than the norm.
To establish whether good economics makes for good politics in general in India, one needs to examine the evidence across several electoral cycles that span high and low growth periods. Moreover, with a voting population that contains a significant proportion of illiterate voters, a related question that arises is: Does the positive effect of growth on re-election prospects hold only in states where the population of literate voters is high? Since literate voters are more likely to be aware of the state of the economy, the effect of good economics on good politics needs to be viewed through this prism. In a recent working paper, we examine these questions using data on all elections – state and national level – from 1980 until 2012.
Our analysis of over 20,000 election outcomes from every constituency over more than three decades reveals the following. First, high economic growth generated by the incumbent government significantly enhances the chances of ruling party candidates getting re-elected. Careful empirical analysis requires controlling for the effects of various other determinants of the incumbents’ success.
Factors that are peculiar to a particular state, such as the leftist leanings of the electorate in states such as West Bengal and Kerala, can influence the incumbent’s ability to get re-elected in that particular state. Moreover, a wave that sweeps the entire nation, such as the sympathy wave generated in the 1984 national elections after Indira Gandhi’s death, can affect all incumbents’ ability to get re-elected. In arriving at our results, we control for such state-level determinants as well as general time trends. Since a higher turnout ratio is considered bad news for the incumbent, we also control for the effect of voter turnout on the likelihood of ruling party candidates getting re-elected.
After controlling for all such determinants, we find that a 1% increase in growth achieved during the entire tenure increases the chances of re-election of every ruling party candidate by 0.6%. Such an increase for every ruling party candidate translates into a significant difference, particularly given three-pronged contests in most constituencies, which include candidates from the two main national parties and from the main regional party in a state.
Second, we find that creating a mirage of economic growth by pushing up growth in the election year can’t mask an incumbent’s incompetence over the entire tenure. Specifically, a government that manufactures growth just in the year of election by inflating the economy is likely to be punished by the voters while a government that achieves high growth throughout its tenure is likely to be rewarded. The above finding goes contrary to political cycle theories where incumbents successfully manipulate economic variables just before the elections and are handsomely rewarded by myopic voters.
William Nordhaus shows that politicians can exploit the Phillips Curve, which posits a negative relation between inflation and unemployment in the short term, to create artificial prosperity just before the election. Since such growth is achieved by inflating the economy, it dies down quickly leading to post-election recessions. Our analysis reveals that Indian voters aren’t myopic in Nordhaus’s sense. Indian politicians, take note.
Third, we examine the effect of the percentage of literate voters in a state on the ruling party candidates’ fortunes. We find that while incumbents are more likely to retain power in states where the population of literate voters is lower, higher economic growth translates into greater prospects of reelection particularly in states where the percentage of literate voters is higher. In other words, not only are illiterate v oters more likely to vote back the incumbent to power, they also care relatively less about economic growth when voting back the incumbent to power. In contrast, literate voters are less likely to vote back the incumbent to power and care a lot about the performance of the incumbent in generating economic growth when deciding whether to vote back the incumbent power or not.
A caveat: a statistical exercise such as ours highlights the average effects observed over more than 20,000 election outcomes spanning more than three decades. However, a few exceptions that constitute statistical outliers don’t necessarily undermine our findings. For example, among the various states, Kerala and Tamil Nadu have the highest percentage of literate voters. Moreover, these states have also enjoyed high economic growth rates. Yet, they also exhibit high levels of bias against the incumbent. In sum, however, our analysis exhorts politicians to take note: good economics can indeed make for good politics!
DISCLAIMER : Any comments, speeches, articles, blogs, podcasts, videos/vlogs, opposite the editorial page/opinions andeditorials page (OP-ED), interview response etc. made by individuals should be accompanied by a clear disclaimer from the ones given below.
“The views expressed in this article are personal. Krishnamurthy Subramanian is a faculty and Prasanna Tantri is Associate Director at the Indian School of Business.”
s6yl58 This is one awesome blog.Really thank you! Keep writing.
I really like your blog post! Quite interesting and informative posts and so original! I’m following yours now!
I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This
piece of writing posted at this site is genuinely nice.
So does this threaten the very character of Mumbai and with it the very idea of Mumbai as a melting pot of cultures where merit and talent count for more than caste, religious or linguistic affiliations? This is after all the home of the film industry, where Muslims have done better than in many other professions. Will we see a day when we will be nothing more than a cluster of ghettos, talking and mixing only when we need to but otherwise going back to our tribes? Is Mumbai as we know and love it, dying?
[url=http://www.lululemonoutlet-canada.tk/]Lululemon Canada[/url]
Lululemon Canada
For this to be truly possible we need to relearn that debate has to be about an idea or an issue, not about people and personalities. We have to learn that disagreeing on an issue doesn
Financial markets were promptly disrupted, especially the . The Aussie dollar slipped beneath parity with . It later collected itself and got back above parity. But the move had more grim determination in it than real conviction. The dollar is on the edge.
Bottes UGG Enfants Bailey Button 5991
Now with that kind of baggage, Modi wants to get away from it. It was just pure opportunism. Congress sort of feared that Modi was capturing Gandhi
Politically, legislators will push against any methodology that portrays their prized policies in a less flattering light. Supply-siders, for instance, favor , because it includes beneficial growth assumptions that make tax cuts appear less costly. At the same time, legislators seeking to portray runaway government would rather not to spending proposals, as they may appear less costly.
Michael Kors Factory
I love to read you website
http://tir.phorum.pl/viewtopic.php?p=3725
http://sse2.phorum.pl/viewtopic.php?p=1303
Interestingly, he told investigators that he had cleared the 2005 civil services preliminary examination.
Just last week, even though the Office for National Statistics left overall second- quarter GDP growth unrevised at 0.7pc, the fine print was disturbing. While household spending was up 0.3pc, business investment the underlying fuel of commerce, and a key indicator for future growth was revised down sharply, registering a shocking 2.7pc decline.
wonderful stuff. good !!!
Concise and written well, thanks for the post
Thought I would comment and say great theme, did you design it on your own? Its really great!
I precisely desired to appreciate you all over again. I do not know what I might have followed in the absence of the entire recommendations contributed by you on such field. It was actually a very troublesome problem for me, however , finding out the very professional tactic you treated it took me to cry for delight. Im thankful for the advice and hope that you recognize what an amazing job that you are putting in teaching others using your blog post. I know that you havent met any of us.
Very good post.
Theres obviously a lot to know about this. I believe you produced some great points in Features also.
An attention-grabbing dialogue is worth comment. I think that it’s best to write extra on this topic, it won’t be a taboo subject nonetheless normally individuals are not sufficient to speak on such topics. Towards the next. Cheers
Oh my goodness! an remarkable write-up dude. Numerous thanks Even so My business is experiencing trouble with ur rss . Do not know why Struggle to sign up to it. Can there be every person getting identical rss dilemma? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx
Pretty good post. Ive really enjoyed browsing your website posts. Whatever the case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon! Thanks a lot, I’ll try to visit often. Merry Chrismas!
This is certainly fascinating How much time do you spend updating this blog every day? I think the second paragraph pretty much says everything.
Awesome post , I am going to spend a lot more time researching this topic
I’m still learning from you, as I’m making my way to the top as well. I definitely liked reading all that is posted on your site.Keep the tips coming. I liked it!
thanks a lot, initial I got losing upon education of 2, after that it is rather uncomplicated rather while i look into the several guidance, excellent thanks!
Nationalists in Scotland, whose waters contain the European Unions biggest reserves of oil and gas, say they want the Bank of England to remain the lender of last resort for financial institutions after possible independence.